NCCAA 1st        NCCAA 2nd      
 First Last Sport Year  First Last Sport Year
 Tom Allen** Wrestling 1989-92  Luke Akins Men's Basketball  1994-95
 Hannah Anderson Women's Soccer  2016-17  Randy Arbogast Men's Soccer  1989-90
 Jean Auckland** Women's Basketball 1985-88  Peter Beers Men's Soccer  1989-90
 Peter Beers Men's Soccer  1990-91  Kim Bond Women's Basketball  2003-04
 Juan Bell Wrestling 1997-98  Jim Bonner Men's Basketball  2004-05
 Lori Biastock* Women's Cross Country  2007-09  Joel Borchardt Men's Basketball  2011-12
 Brent Biddle Wrestling 1989-90  Pam Borchardt* Volleyball  2013-15
 Kim Bond Women's Basketball  2004-05  Ross Boucher Men's Soccer  1985-86
 Kim Bond Women's Volleyball  2006-07  Juliana Brahs Women's Cross Country  2009-10
 Joel Borchardt Men's Basketball  2012-13  Clayton Callan Men's Basketball  2002-03
 Betsy Borstad Women's Cross Country  2006-07  Nadine Callan Volleyball  2004-05
 Ross Boucher Men's Soccer  1986-87  Peter Catalano Men's Soccer  1985-86
 Juliana Brahs Women's Cross Country  2008-09  Lisa Collogan Women's Soccer  2009-10
 Mark Brock* Men's Basketball  1999-01  Bruce Cournoyer* Men's Soccer  1986-88
 John Bruner^ Wrestling 1995-96  Anna Dahl Women's Soccer  2014-15
 Nadine Callan* Women's Volleyball  2005-07  Kedra DeLozier Volleyball  2008-09
 Todd Campbell* Wrestling 1990-92  Andrew DeLozier Men's Soccer  2012-13
 Troy Campbell Wrestling 1994-95  Courtney Dunn Women's Soccer  2013-14
 Terrell Cannon* Men's Basketball  1989-91  Angela Fenstermacher Women's Soccer  2006-07
 Lisa Collogan* Women's Soccer  2008-09, 2010-11  Colleen Goff Women's Basketball  2006-07
 Drew DeLozier* Men's Soccer  2013-15  Chester Gunnin Men's Basketball  1996-97
 Torey DeLozier***^^ Women's Volleyball  2009-13  Alison Hernandez* Women's Soccer  2015-17
 Torey DeLozier Women's Basketball  2011-12  Randy Hockema Men's Soccer  1991-92
 Brenda DeVore Women's Volleyball  1996-97  Elise Jones Women's Soccer  2008-09
 Misty Donough Women's Basketball  2001-02  Dan Kaminski Men's Soccer  2007-08
 Courtney Dunn* Women's Soccer  2014-16  James Keith Men's Soccer  1988-89
 Jocelyn Enrique Women's Soccer  2012-13  Ethan Kennon* Football 2013-15
 Nathan Foster Men's Basketball  1993-94  Gabrael Kluver Football 2013-14
 Laura Frazee Women's Soccer  2005-06  Ethan Lane Football 2012-13
 Hanna Glaze Women's Basketball  2016-17  Lynelle Larson Women's Basketball  1998-99
 Colleen Goff Women's Basketball  2007-08  Charles Leeds Men's Soccer  2014-15
 Jacob Gomez Men's Basketball  2002-03  Jeremy Leffring Men's Soccer  1999-00
 Al Gruenwald*** Wrestling 1989-93  Brian Lundquist Men's Soccer  2012-13
 Jim Gruenwald*^ Wrestling 1990-92  Nathan Lyle Men's Soccer  2011-12
 Nancy Hauter* Women's Volleyball  1988-90  Ben Matthews Men's Basketball  1995-96
 Chelle Hogsett* Women's Volleyball  1993-94, 1995-96  Alicia Michaelsen* Women's Basketball  2001-02, 2004-05
 Katie Holbrook** Women's Cross Country  2014-17  Shasta Miklowski Women's Soccer  2007-08
 Julie Hon* Women's Volleyball  1993-95  Kristin Morrison Women's Basketball  2010-11
 Scott Ice Wrestling 1993-94  Melissa Nichols* Women's Soccer  2006-08
 Alexis Johnson Women's Volleyball  2016-17  David Orns Men's Basketball  1996-97
 Julie Johnson Women's Basketball  1990-91  Samantha Pagel Volleyball  2010-11
 Elise Jones Women's Soccer  2010-11  Holly Peterson* Volleyball  2007-09
 Brian Keith Men's Soccer  1989-90  Laci Peterson* Women's Basketball  2011-12, 2013-14
 Andy Kepply Wrestling 1997-98  Taylor Pill* Men's Soccer  2012-14
 John Kincaid* Men's Soccer  1986-88  Don Reynolds Men's Basketball  1989-90
 Michael Kluver Men's Cross Country  2014-15  Eric Schooley* Men's Basketball  1990-91, 1992-93
 Joshua Kruit Men's Cross Country  2015-16  Ben Schulz* Football 2015-17
 Rob Kurtz Men's Soccer  1990-91  Lauren Schulz Volleyball  2013-14
 Emily Kutz Women's Soccer  2009-10  Andrew Solarek Men's Soccer  2008-09
 Lynelle Larson Women's Basketball  1996-97  Priscilla Spate Women's Basketball  1999-00
 Chris Leppert Wrestling 1996-97  Lauren Stephens Women's Cross Country  2009-10
 Cathy LeTourneau** Women's Volleyball  1993-96  Natascha Vinz Women's Soccer  2013-14
 Cathy LeTourneau Women's Basketball  1994-95  Wira Wama Men's Soccer  2013-14
 Harmony Lorch Women's Soccer  2013-14  Eddie Washetas Men's Basketball  2001-02
 Alysha Morris Women's Soccer  2012-13        
 Amanda Moses Women's Basektball  2008-09        
 Julie Muse Women's Soccer  2008-09        
 Monica Netzel Women's Volleyball  2001-02        
 Scott Nichols Men's Soccer  1990-91        
 Melissa Nichols Women's Soccer  2008-09        
 Bryan Oliver Men's Soccer  2008-09        
 William O'Malley Men's Cross Country  2012-13        
 David Orns* Men's Basketball  1997-99        
 Autumn Peotter Women's Basketball  2012-13        
 Laci Peterson** Women's Volleyball  2011-14        
 Laci Peterson Women's Basketball  2012-13        
 Rose Peterson Women's Basektball  2008-09        
 Taylor Pill Men's Soccer  2014-15        
 Steve Price Wrestling 1990-91        
 Michelle Reeves Women's Volleyball  1989-90        
 Shelley Reeves** Women's Volleyball  1990-92        
 Stacy Reinke* Women's Volleyball  2014-16        
 Don Rekoske Men's Basketball 1985-86        
 Alison Renz**^^ Women's Volleyball  2014-17        
 Audrey Risma*^* Women's Soccer  2014-17        
 Stephen Roby Men's Soccer  2004-05        
 Karis Rogers* Women's Soccer  2010-12        
 Sandi Schafer* Women's Volleyball  1990-92        
 Angela Seeley Women's Basketball 1998-99        
 Isaiah Steinbart Men's Cross Country 2008-09        
 Alison Steinhouse Women's Soccer  2012-13        
 Tim Stephens Wrestling 1994-95        
 Peter Struska Men's Cross Country  2008-09        
 Elisa Sutherland* Women's Cross Country  2002-04        
 Patty VanDenBerghe* Women's Basketball  1999-01        
 Natascha Vinz Women's Soccer  2015-16        
 Caleb Wagner Men's Cross Country  2015-16        
 Lianna Walburg Women's Cross Country  2002-03        
 Amanda Walton Women's Soccer  2016-17        
 Wira Wama**^ Men's Soccer  2014-17        
 Dan Willis** Wrestling 1990-93        
 Joe Zammit Wrestling 1993-94




* Denotes additional year being named All-American

^ Denotes NCCAA Player of the Year Honor